Getting a backup ID - worth it?

I've been researching fake IDs for about a month now, comparing different vendors, reading reviews everywhere I can find them. This site keeps coming up as top-tier, but the price is noticeably higher than some competitors.

The question: Is premium quality really worth paying 30-40% more?

I've seen some sites offering IDs for $70-80, while this site charges $110-130+ depending on the state. That's a significant price difference when you're a broke college student.

My concerns:
• Don't want to waste money on cheap quality that doesn't work
• But also don't want to overpay if "premium" is just marketing
• Need something reliable but budget is definitely a factor

What I'm hoping to learn:
1. Has anyone ordered from both budget and premium vendors? What's the actual difference?
2. Do cheap IDs actually work or are they obviously fake?
3. Is this site's quality genuinely better or just more expensive?
4. What's the success rate with budget IDs vs premium?

I only need this for occasional use - convenience stores, maybe some bars. Not trying to get into exclusive clubs or anything high-stakes. Does that change the equation?

Really appreciate honest input from people who have experience with multiple vendors. Help a student make a smart decision! 🙏